DOCTRINE OF THE OLD TESTAMENT WORTHIES
Does the Bible teach that the individuals mentioned in Matthew 27:52-53 (referred to as Old Testament Worthies) would rise from the dead, or is it merely a false traditional belief that has been misrepresented as a fact?
Traditionally derived doctrines, like any other tradition created by the media, begin with a simple idea. By blending small truths and small untruths, the traditional incidental doctrine arrives at a conclusion that is not accurate overall. The authors use minor changes to the truth to cause immeasurable impact and damage, turning a true doctrine into a false doctrine. When a false doctrine serves as the foundation or support for another false doctrine, the truth becomes obscured and lost amidst the complexities of theology and religion.
Incorporating incidental doctrines can influence a desired outcome for both teacher and student, which increases the appeal of acceptance. A traditional doctrine's value is in its ability to grow in any direction necessary to bolster other more desired doctrines that use the associated traditional doctrine as their lynchpin. The doctrine of the Old Testament Worthies is an incidental traditional doctrine. However, it did not need to become a false doctrine, if taught correctly!
From my earliest memories of learning about Bible stories, the Old Testament Worthies doctrine has played a significant part in my life. Its impact was that it taught that God gave a third resurrection to people outside of the first and second resurrections, which did not coincide with other fundamental doctrines.
Preachers and teachers taught and still teach this traditional doctrine in church, Sunday school, and Vacation Bible School. There is a lack of substance in the Old Testament Worthies doctrine. My former pastor, and in particular my late father, Rev. Charles Cohenour Sr., taught sparingly on this subject. When he did, he used few words before moving on to the main topic of his sermon. I believe my father reasoned that there was not enough proof on which to base this traditional teaching. Questioning from the congregation would lead to assumptions, and my father did not wish to teach assumptions.
In my teenage years, our family was frequently invited to General Meetings, Regional Meetings, and Minister Meetings held by different churches of the Body of Christ throughout the USA. We traveled to places as far away as Chino, California, and as near as Indianapolis, Indiana, with many places in between. By traveling to other churches in the Body of Christ, I was occasionally exposed to the doctrine of the Old Testament Worthies. That doctrine was taught only sparsely during those visits; however, it was presented as biblical truth many times.
The person who first preached this doctrine was the late Bro. William Sowders, the founder of our Body of Christ. By preaching his interpretation of Matthew 27:52–53, he turned this incidental teaching into an accepted traditional doctrine in our Body of Christ today. When Bro. Sowders taught the doctrine, it was quickly accepted by the saints of the BOC. Bro. Sowders was rarely questioned about this doctrine, and the doctrine became an accepted tradition that is now presented as pure and godly truth. Even after Bro. Sowders died, the Old Testament Worthies doctrine is still taught throughout the country as it was during his lifetime. Bro. Sowders taught this more than 68 years ago.
The Old Testament Worthies doctrine is used as a foundation for other doctrines, such as the Doctrine of Perfection and the Doctrine of the First and Second Resurrections. The Old Testament Worthies doctrine has a specific application regarding the Doctrine of Moving Out a Living Soul and the Doctrine of Those Waiting Under the Golden Altar. According to God's Old Testament Worthies doctrine, all the heroes of the Bible are in heaven, under the Golden Altar, in the First Resurrection.
This Doctrine of the Old Testament Worthies addresses God's alleged sovereign right to allow certain exceptions to His established law. The Doctrine suggests that God can operate outside His own standards — suggesting that Almighty God may break His own oaths and lie as He pleases.
This doctrine also challenges human standards of what is fair and equal among church members. It teaches that the accumulation of acts of Christian behavior warrants godly favoritism. It likewise reinforces a misconception that God shows partiality by giving certain elect, predestined individuals preferential treatment.
The key question: Is this doctrine a truthful interpretation of Scripture or a false traditional assumption preached as truth?
The problem is that although the Apostle Matthew did write about a resurrection in Matthew 27, he left that specific resurrection open-ended, recording it simply as a church miracle. That open-ended miracle left an opening for someone to exploit by reasoning about it and propagating an agreeable doctrine — one suited to those who, by subtle means, built a doctrine that could be used to advance their own agenda.
For many, many years, books have been written and sermons preached about this resurrection without challenge. I believe there are unanswered questions concerning later interpretations of Matthew 27:52–53 — questions that have gone unchallenged and that need to be brought into the open.
There is definite truth in Matthew 27:52–53. We just need to see it and teach it correctly. This resurrection happened, but not as we have been taught.
Sincerely,
Charles E. Cohenour Jr.
December 15, 2020
“If I am to be true to my calling, I must exercise my gift. I am called to be a teacher; I should always bring to the children of the Lord a lesson to learn”.
Charles E. Cohenour Jr. 12-04-2014
Addendum: There are many doctrines that are preached and taught as the gospel that have never been labeled. I have labeled some in this text according to their subjects. When you read about a doctrine, you may or may not have heard of it anywhere else. I apologize if I seem to be drawing attention to a way of teaching a subject that may not have had a label in the distant past.
Special thanks for all the editing and help given by my wife, Jean Cohenour, who spent many hours correcting my horrid spelling and grammar. Without Jean, this article would never have been written or understood. Thank you also to those who helped proofread and provided input in the early writing. May God bless you all.